Give me Joe Mantegna and William H. Macy as partners and I'll guarantee that there will be a movie worth watching. Macy has been moving up the chain, and is brilliant here.
The whole issue of Jewish persecution is woven in the story, and Mantegna is conflicted because he is Jewish, but obviously not a practicing one. As things go, his Jewishness is challenged by the investigation. "You say you are a Jew, and you can't read Hebrew. What are you then?" He is finally confronted with the reality of hate and his role as a cop takes second place to his Jewishness.
It is about realizing that he is nowhere until he finds out who he really is. The language of the police is raw and brings everything out into the open. Detective Gold (Mantegna) doesn't find himself at the end of the film. He has a ways to go, but now he has a direction.
Homicide
1991
Action / Crime / Drama / Mystery / Thriller
Homicide
1991
Action / Crime / Drama / Mystery / Thriller
Plot summary
A Jewish homicide detective investigates a seemingly minor murder and falls in with a Zionist group as a result.
Uploaded by: FREEMAN
August 26, 2024 at 06:00 AM
Director
Top cast
Tech specs
720p.BLU 1080p.BLU 720p.WEB 1080p.WEBMovie Reviews
The FBI couldn't find Joe Frazier in a bowl of rice.
David Mamet's Best Film?
A Jewish homicide detective (Joe Mantegna, who is not Jewish) investigates a seemingly minor murder and falls in with a Zionist group as a result.
I can't say I have seen all of David Mamet's films, but I have seen enough to know that he is an excellent writer of dialogue. He is a solid director, too, but it is the dialogue that sets his films apart. And this is no exception, going between a good cop story and a much deeper exploration of what it means to be Jewish. (What is the meaning of the Esther scene? I don't know.) What does it mean to be Jewish? But really, what does it mean to be anything? I can't really identify, because I am a great many different ethnicities and feel no allegiance to any one or feel that one is "who I am". Can a bloodline really define who a person is?
Mamet film
Homicide detectives Bobby Gold (Joe Mantegna) and Tim Sullivan (William H. Macy) were taken off the case of Robert Randolph in favor of the FBI. The FBI fumbles the arrest. With mounting racial resentment, the mayor orders the cops to take him alive. Gold stumbles onto a murder of an old Jewish grandmother who ran a store in a black neighborhood. The rumor is that she kept a fortune in the basement. The Jewish family uses their political influence to get Gold as the investigator. Gold is frustrated at losing the Randolph case. He's also not a proud Jew and dismisses this case which would test his Jewish ethnicity.
It's David Mamet writing and directing. The dialogue has his mannered style. It's hard-boiled. The visual style is stark. Some of it is off-putting. He's hitting the Jew card very hard right from the start. It's unnecessary. The central concept is intriguing. However, little things keep annoying me. Gold's gun gets taken and fired by a prisoner but there is no investigation afterwards. It shouldn't be up to Gold. There is supposedly a gunman across the way but they don't close the curtains. There are little problems all the way to the end. The most problematic is that Gold's switch feels too abrupt. In fact, I figured he's lying to them to pump for information. In general, the movie doesn't feel natural. There is an intriguing idea but I can't completely buy it.